You’re not going crazy. Broadway’s Best WAS located on 467 West Broadway. On Wednesday, they did just move a half a block up Broadway to the old Amsterdam Cafe location at 483 East Broadway.
If you’re sad the Amsterdam is gone because you’ll mix their frozen yogurt with mix-ins, don’t worry! Broadway’s Best has the same frozen yogurt!
We’ll take ours with Oreo and Reese’s!
Image of the changing of the signs via CIS roving photographer Karen Regan. Thanks Karen!