Still Not Lovin’ It: Residents Opposed to West Broadway McDonald’s

Neighbors are not loving the prospect of a McDonald’s opening near Perkins Square, operating from 5 a.m. to 1 a.m. The franchise plans to open at 474 West Broadway, in the old Santander Bank, across from a suite of other fast-food restaurants at one of the neighborhood’s busiest intersections.
Neighbors have raised concerns about trash, pest control, and traffic stemming from mobile orders. Councilor Ed Flynn said his office has received complaints from residents and the St. Vincent’s Lower End Neighborhood Association.
“This location in Perkins Square is already dealing with existing issues of pedestrian and public safety with double-parked vehicles, as well as third-party delivery mopeds that continue to completely disregard the rules of the road by running red lights, stop signs, driving the wrong way down the street, and on sidewalks at high rates of speed,” the councilor said in a statement last week.
At an abutter’s meeting on Monday, Flynn said his opposition is “not personal against McDonald’s,” but that the location is unsuitable for a fast-food restaurant.
“This proposal is not a good fit. I’m really asking the McDonald’s company to withdraw the proposal based on the lack of support from the residents.” He also called on the Mayor’s office to “come off the sidelines” and show residents in South Boston it cares about their quality of life.
A few residents shared that the location would be good for seniors looking for a cheap meal in an accessible location, but the bulk of community feedback was deeply critical of the new location.
With multiple bus stops, other restaurants, and foot traffic from both residents and visitors, neighbors called the location “a burden on the community.” The street also has its share of fast food with Taco Bell, 7th St Burger, and South Boston’s own Burger King just up the road. Neighbors have long voiced concern that having all these establishments so close together has increased loitering and the presence of third-party delivery drivers blocking the street.
The proposed location is also roughly a mile from two other McDonald’s locations, in South Station and Dorchester, the former of which has a drive-through and is better equipped to handle delivery orders.
McDonald’s hours were also a point of concern. One neighbor said that closing at 1 a.m. every night would be an “aberration” compared to Anna’s Taqueria, which closes at 11 p.m., and Taco Bell and 7th St. Burger, which only remain open until 1 a.m. on weekends.
Attorney Dennis Quilty, speaking for McDonald’s, said that they would be responsible to the community and licensing board for issues in the restaurant, but things like traffic and crime would be beyond the restaurant’s control.
“Unfortunately, the double parking and the scooters, we all see them everywhere. It’s really an enforcement situation,” Quilty said. “We’d be looking to cooperate with the councilor’s office, with the police department and every other agency to do our part to do what we can. I think the concept of the food lockers will help somewhat.”
He added that the restaurants would still pursue a 1 a.m. license, arguing that it was consistent with other restaurants in the area.
Area Construction Manager Eric Wagner said he would keep much of the building’s original brickwork, with changes to capture the “McDonald’s look.”
The basement level would receive upgraded electrical systems but would otherwise remain unfinished. The first floor would be a fully self-contained restaurant, with a vestibule containing 12 code-protected pickup lockers for orders from the McDonald’s app or third-party food delivery. The upper two floors would not be used and would remain unfinished. The rear of the building would be used for deliveries twice a week. Wagner added that McDonald’s would work with neighbors to keep these deliveries unobtrusive.
No operator for the franchise has been selected, but Quilty added he hopes it would be someone “familiar with the community.”
McDonald’s will appear before the Boston Licensing Board at an upcoming, unspecified date.

Jacob Downey is a contributor to Caught in Dot. He is formerly of The Clock, Plymouth State University’s award-winning student newspaper. He enjoys spending time with his two kittens – Gin and Tonic – reading Uncanny X-Men and writing about local government meetings.

Traffic Alert: Thousands of Uber and Lyft Drivers Expected to Rally Near UMass Boston on Tuesday
Mayor Wu Proposes Changes to Boston’s Affordable Housing Rules to Encourage New Development
South Boston Resident Rachel Pearson to Challenge Ed Flynn for City Council Seat in 2027